Guide · October 2026
Tax office assessment too high? How to prove the lower market value
If you inherit a property or receive one as a gift, the tax office assigns it a value calculated using a simplified method. If the actual market value is lower, you can prove it under Section 198 of the German Valuation Act (BewG) with an expert appraisal. We explain when this pays off, which appraisals the tax office accepts and which deadlines apply.
For inheritance and gift tax, the tax office values property using standardised methods. It works with standard land values, flat-rate construction costs and market averages. The condition of the individual building, damage, a maintenance backlog or encumbrances such as a right of way are barely reflected. As a result, the assessed property value is sometimes well above the price that could actually be achieved on the market.
Section 198 BewG covers exactly this case. Owners may prove that the fair market value is lower. If the proof succeeds, the tax office uses the lower value.
When is an appraisal for the tax office worthwhile?
An appraisal pays off when the tax office's value is noticeably above the realistic market value and tax is actually due as a result. Typical cases:
- Houses in need of renovation or modernisation, for example because of an old heating system, damp or a roof at the end of its service life
- Plots with third-party rights such as a right of way, a utility easement or a public-law building encumbrance (Baulast)
- Listed buildings where conservation requirements restrict use and modernisation
- Plots with an unusual shape, a difficult location or heavy noise exposure
- Apartment buildings whose rents are permanently below market, for example because of a rent restriction
You do not need an appraisal if no tax is due anyway. That is the case if the acquisition stays within the allowances, for example EUR 500,000 for spouses and EUR 400,000 for children, or if the family home passes tax-free under certain conditions. Whether an appraisal pays off therefore depends on the tax that can be saved. It is best to clarify this with your tax adviser in advance. We provide the professional assessment of the value in an initial consultation.
A simplified example
A daughter inherits a detached house in Hamburg from her mother. There are no other assets. The tax office assesses the property value at EUR 1,150,000. Because of considerable renovation needs, an appraisal arrives at a market value of EUR 900,000.
- With the tax office's value: EUR 1,150,000 minus the EUR 400,000 allowance leaves EUR 750,000. At a tax rate of 19 per cent, that is EUR 142,500 in inheritance tax.
- With the appraisal: EUR 900,000 minus EUR 400,000 leaves EUR 500,000. At 15 per cent, that is EUR 75,000.
The difference is EUR 67,500. The example is deliberately simple: other allowances, debts of the estate and costs are left out. Your tax adviser calculates your actual tax.
Which appraisals does the tax office accept?
Since 2023, Section 198 BewG states explicitly who may provide the proof: the locally responsible valuation board (Gutachterausschuss) or a publicly appointed and sworn expert for the valuation of real estate. Experts certified under DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024 are also accepted. An estate agent's estimate or the result of an online calculator is not sufficient. In terms of content, the appraisal must follow the rules of the German Real Estate Valuation Ordinance (ImmoWertV).
Hauke Kruse has been publicly appointed and sworn by the Hamburg Chamber of Commerce since 2001 for the valuation of developed and undeveloped land. Our appraisals therefore meet the legal requirement regarding the person of the expert.
Instead of an appraisal, a purchase price can also serve as proof: if the property was sold in the ordinary course of business within one year before or after the valuation date and nothing significant has changed in the meantime.
What the tax office checks
The tax office is not bound by an appraisal. It checks whether the value has been derived comprehensibly and may reject an appraisal. In practice, questions arise mainly on these points:
- Valuation date: What counts is the date of death or the date of the gift, not the date of the inspection. Standard land values and market data must match that date.
- Deductions: Anyone who takes damage or renovation needs into account must document them and assess them in line with the market. Simply deducting the full contractor costs is usually not enough.
- Basis: The values must be based on an inspection and on documents named in the appraisal.
- Rights of use: Whether a usufruct or a right of residence reduces the value in the appraisal or is deducted separately for tax purposes must be clearly separated. Otherwise there is a risk of a double deduction, which the tax office will strike out.
What the Hamburg tax office requires
For properties in Hamburg, the Finanzamt für Verkehrsteuern und Grundbesitz in Hamburg examines the evidence. It has published its own guidance sheet on this. Beyond the points mentioned above, it states:
- Short-form appraisals are not sufficient. A complete appraisal with all annexes is required.
- The appraisal must include a site plan and labelled colour photographs of the interior and exterior.
- Any deviation from the standard land value (Bodenrichtwert) must be explained in a comprehensible way.
- If a purchase price serves as evidence, the date of the notarised purchase contract counts for the one-year period.
The appraisals submitted are reviewed by the tax administration's own building experts. The responsible expert committee is the Gutachterausschuss für Grundstückswerte in Hamburg. Its office is part of the Landesbetrieb Geoinformation und Vermessung, the city's surveying agency. Hamburg's standard land values can be looked up free of charge in the BORIS.HH portal.
Which deadlines apply?
The tax office determines the property value in a separate notice, the Feststellungsbescheid. The objection is directed against this notice, not against the later inheritance or gift tax assessment. The objection period is one month after notification.
The appraisal does not have to be finished within this period. As a rule, it is enough to lodge an objection in time and announce that an appraisal will follow. If the tax office sets a deadline for this, take it seriously and talk to us early. The easiest way is to check whether an appraisal makes sense before filing the property value declaration. It can then be submitted together with the declaration. Your tax adviser or lawyer handles the objection and the deadlines.
Does this also apply to property tax?
No. Section 198 BewG applies to inheritance and gift tax and, in certain cases, to real estate transfer tax. Since 2025, Hamburg has calculated property tax (Grundsteuer) using its own model, which is based on floor area and residential location and does not use a market value. A market value appraisal therefore does not reduce Hamburg property tax.
How the process works with us
- You send us the notice or the request to file the property value declaration, together with the documents you already have.
- We assess whether a significantly lower value is to be expected and tell you openly if an appraisal is not worthwhile.
- We inspect the property and value it as of the valuation date, even if that date lies months or years in the past.
- You receive the appraisal as a PDF with a qualified electronic signature (QES). You or your tax adviser can submit it directly to the tax office.
Questions about your property? We will tell you which appraisal you need.
Briefly describe the occasion and the property. We will get back to you with an initial professional assessment.
More articles
Guide · November 2026
Hamburg's tax office for transfer taxes and real property: what it handles and when an appraisal helps
Anyone who inherits, receives or buys a property in Hamburg deals with a tax office many people have never heard of. We explain what the Finanzamt für Verkehrsteuern und Grundbesitz is responsible for, which notices it issues and in which cases a market value appraisal can lower the tax value.
Read moreGuide · October 2026
Inherited or gifted property: how the process works at the tax office
When a property is inherited or given away, two units at the tax office work together: the valuation unit determines the value of the property, and the inheritance tax unit calculates the tax. We show the process, who is responsible for what, where an objection belongs and when you should bring in an expert.
Read moreGuide · October 2026
Calculating usufruct and right of residence: how the tax office determines the capital value
If you give away a property and reserve a usufruct or a right of residence, the gift tax goes down. The German Valuation Act sets out how much the right is worth for tax purposes: annual value times multiplier. We show the calculation with the current 2026 table and an example.
Read more